8/05/2005

【辭典】vacate、reverse、dismiss

【辭典】vacate、reverse、dismiss

應該是這樣吧,我覺得。

FindLaw :vacate 廢棄,上級法院廢棄下級法院的判決,且不做任何的“判決”,原告應重新提起訴訟。
1: to make void: 'annul' 'set aside'
Example: vacate a lower court order
2 a: to make vacant
b: to give up the occupancy of: to vacate an office, post, or tenancy"

law.com Law Dictionary: vacate v.
1) for a judge to set aside or annul an order or judgment which he/she finds was improper.
2) to move out of real estate and cease occupancy.

FindLaw :reverse 推翻或改判,上級法院推翻下級法院的判決,並且做出相反判決。
to set aside or make void (a judgment or decision) by a contrary decision (compare affirm): to reverse a decision or judgment
Example: for these reasons, we reverse"

FindLaw:dismiss 不受理或撤銷,
1: to remove from position or service
Example: dismissed the employee
2: to bring about or order the dismissal of (an action)
Example: the suit was dismissed: to bring about or order a dismissal
Example: the plaintiff moved to dismiss
【8月23日更新】
例如,當法院覺得沒有 jurisdiction 的時候,就用不受理:Because the district court’s initial order did not address Brinkmann’s invalidity counterclaim, this court determined that it lacked jurisdiction and dismissed the appeal.


見此判例
In Transonic Systems, Inc. v. Non-Invasive Medical Technologies Corporation (No. 04-1546; July 25, 2005), the Federal Circuit reverses a district court's claim construction, and vacates a judgment of non-infringement and a prosecution history estoppel ruling.

claim construction 使用 reverse ;而 judgement 使用 vacate 。

先前還曾看過臺灣的判決,它裡面的用字是:行政處分用“撤銷”;法院的判決則用“廢棄”。




====================================================

這幾個字我常分不清楚vacate、reverse、dismiss,就算查了線上的法律字典,分不清楚,它們在看判決時很常出現。有哪位前輩知道這些字是什麼意思的,請您不吝分享(ides13@gmail.com),謝謝。

沒有留言: